Sympathectomy: "suppression of the neuroendocrine stress response"

p.254

Neuraxial blocks typically produce variable decrease in blood pressure that might be accompanied by a decrease in heart rate and cardiac contractility. These effects are generally proportional to the degree (level) of the sympathectomy. Vasomotor tone is primarily determined by sympathetic fibres arising from T5 to L1, innervating arterial and venous smooth muscle. Blocking these nerves causes vasodilation of the venous capacitance vessels, pooling of blood, and decreased vvenous terurn to the heart; in some instances, arterial vasodilation may also decrease systemic vascular resistance. The effects of arterial vasodilation may be minimized by compensatory vasoconstriction above the level of the block. A high sympathetic block not only prevents compensatory vasoconstriction but also blocks the sympathetic cardiac accelerator fibres that arise at T1-T4.
Profound hypotension may result from vasodilation combined with bradycardia and decreased contractility. These effects are further exaggerated if venous return is further compromised by a head-up position or from the weight of a gravid uterus. Unopposed vagal tone in some persons may explain cardiac arrest with spinal anesthesia.
p.261

The sympathetic system normally maintains some tonic vasoconstriction on the vascular tree. Loss off this tone following induction of anesthesia or sympathectomy frequently contributes to perioperative hypotension.
p.375

AV conduction abnormalities are usually manifested by abnormal ventricular depolarization (bundle-branch block) prolongation of the P-R interval (first degree AV block) failure of some atrial impulses to depolarize the ventricles (second degree AV block) or AV dissociation (third degree AV block or complete heart block).
p.428

Clinical anesthesiology By G. Edward Morgan, Maged S. Mikhail, Michael J. Murray
McGraw-Hill, Edition: 3 - 2002

Lack of disclosure to ETS patients is unethical and would be criminal in a just society

It is the doctor's moral and ethical duty to provide you with full and honest disclosure of the facts prior to surgery. The whole doctrine of informed consent is to prevent patients from having to realize they made a mistake in hindsight. You shouldn't have had to find out from a former patient's wife that the surgery would cause drenching sweating on your back. It was Garza's job to do that. He completely lied to you regarding the supposed reversibility. Anyone who goes through medical school knows that can't crush a nerve with a metal clamp, remove it later and have the nerve return to normal functioning.

Although it is not possible to predict exactly what will occur in each individual case, there is nearly 100 years of published scientific and medical research available on the effects of sympathectomy. That research paints a very different picture of the effects of this surgery than the one presented to patients considering this surgery. That's the issue. Generally, they lie and tell patients that CS is inconsequential in all but a tiny fraction of cases and simply fail to disclose a huge number of verified adverse effects of the surgery. They take advantage of the patient's ignorance on medical matter. It's unethical and would be criminal in a just society.

In short, you do have a way of knowing what will likely occur as a result of the surgery before you have it done. All the information necessary to make an informed decision exists. It's just not getting to patients.

http://etsandreversals.yuku.com/reply/22927/Would-you-do-it-again#reply-22927

Sympathectomy interfering with high blood pressure drug?

Tell your doctor if you have any of
the following medical conditions:
* kidney problems
* liver problems
* heart problems
* diabetes
* recent excessive vomiting or
diarrhoea
* Systemic Lupus Erythematosus
(SLE), a disease affecting the
skin, joints and kidneys
* a salt restricted diet
* a past operation known as
sympathectomy
If you have not told your doctor about any of the above, tell him/her before you start taking Atacand Plus 16/12.5.

Atacand Plus 16/12.5 is used to treat high blood pressure.

The Cochrane Review of ETS - 2003

”The practice of surgical and chemical sympathectomy is based on poor quality evidence, uncontrolled studies and personal experience.“

Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2003;(2):CD002918.

Surgical sympathectomy listed as neurologic disorder

Other neurologic disorders
- Idiopathic orthostatic hypotension
- Multiple sclerosis
- Parkinsonism
- Posterior fossa tumor
- Shy-Drager syndrome
- Spinal cord injury with paraplegia
- Surgical sympathectomy
- Syringomyelia
- Syringobulbia
- Tabes dorsales (syphillis)
- Wernicke's encephalopathy
Dizziness: Classification and Pathophysiology
The Journal of Manual and Manipulative Therapy, Vol. 12, No 4 (2004)

anatomic variations of the T2 nerve root

6 (9.1%) sides showed a single large ganglion formed by the stellate and the second thoracic sympathetic ganglia. The second thoracic sympathetic ganglion was most commonly located (50%) in the second intercostal space. Conclusion: The anatomic variations of the intrathoracic nerve of Kuntz and the second thoracic sympathetic ganglion were characterized in human cadavers.

Journal of thoracic and cardiovascular surgery Y. 2002, vol. 123, No. 3, pages 498-501 [bibl. : 14 ref.

http://www.refdoc.fr/Detailnotice?idarticle=9466218

Risks during Thoracic Sympathectomy - Surgery not as safe as reported

T(2)-T(3) ganglionectomy significantly decreases pulse rate and systolic blood pressure, reduces myocardial oxygen demand, increases left ventricular ejection fraction and prolongs Q-T interval. A certain loss of lung volume and decrease of pulmonary diffusion capacity for CO result from sympathectomy. Histomorphological muscle changes and neuro-histochemical and biochemical effects have also been observed.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/14673672

 

a significant impairment of the heart rate to workload relationship was consistently observed following sympathectomy

Several reports also demonstrate significantly lower heart rate increases during exercise in subjects who have undergone bilateral ISS [9–12] compared to pre-surgical levels. In spite of this high occurrence, recent reviews on the usual collateral effects of thoracic sympathectomy still do not include these possible cardiac consequences [6].
The aim of the present prospective study was to confirm that a significant impairment of the heart rate to workload relationship was consistently observed following unilateral and/or bilateral surgery.
Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 2001;20:1095-1100
http://ejcts.ctsnetjourna...i/content/full/20/6/1095

 

disturbed peripheral vascular and heart rate responses after sympathectomy

Thoracic sympathectomy can result in reduced sweating and disturbed peripheral vascular and heart rate responses. Patients should be warned that these mechanisms may play a role in the development of exertional heat stroke.

Alan D.L. Sihoe, FRCSEd(CTh)^a,_*, Raymond W.T. Liu, MRCP^b, Alex K.L. Lee, MRCP^b, Chak-Wah Lam, FHKAM^b, Lik-Cheung Cheng, FRCS

 

Even epidural blockade limited only to the thoracic dermatomes is liable to cause complete sympathectomy, including cardiac sympathetic denervation. The ensuing vasodilation and bradycardia lead to hypotension, poor tolerance of mechanical interference with the heart, and inability to respond to acute changes in intravascular volume or body position. This symptom complex is especially troublesome to manage during intrathoracic operations when avoidance of hypervolemia is emphasized.

Thoracic sympathectomy has two other potenital consequences: effect on bronchomotor tone and effect on oxygenation.

During intrathoracic procedures using one-lung ventilation, a right-to-left intrapulmonary shunt is intentionally created (in the form of the nonventilated lung). The ensuing arterial oxygen tension (PaO2) is determined by a complex interaction involving cardiac output, mixed venous oxygen tension, the status of the ventilated lung, size of the shunt, and most significantly, hypoxic pulmonary vasoconstriction (HPV).
HPV diverts pulmonary blood flow away from the shunt by vavsoconstriction in the nonventilated lung, and is the principal adaptive defense mechanism against arterial hypoxemia during one-lung ventilation. The cellular mechanism and regulation of HPV, and the possible role of the autonomic nervous system are not completely understood.
The effect of thoracic sympathectomy of HPV is even less well understood. Since potent vasodilators such as nitroprusside antagonize HPV-induced vasoconstriction and lower the arterial oxygen tension, it is reasonable to assume that HPV will become less effective with thoracic sympathectomy.
Clinical studies have produced conflicting conclusions, most probably because direct measurement of HPV is not possible in human studies, and the surrogate endpoing examined PaO2 is determined not only by HPV, but also by a host of interacting factors, some of which may be affected by the sympathectomy and can not be held constant.

Risk Factor for Neuraxial Anesthesia-Associated Bradycardia:
Block height higher than T5
Younger age

Spinal and Epidural Anesthesia By Cynthia Wong

Publication Date: 2007-01-01 Publisher: MCGRAW-HILL EDUCATION - EUROPE Country of origin: UNITED STATES

After thoracoscopic sympathectomy for hyperhidrosis, very severe discomfort and hyperhidrosis in the neighboring non-sympathectomized regions occurred with alarming frequency and intensity. (p.879)

Alteration in Cerebral Blood Flow after sympathectomy

Jeng and associates observed an increase in cerebral blood flow after T2 sympathectomy, and they suggested the possibility of using such a surgical approach to improve cerebral blood flow in patients with cerebral vascular insufficiency.

Youmans Neurological Surgery, 5th Edition
Publisher: Saunders
Publication Date: 2003-10-10

Sympathetic nerves protect against blood-brain barrier disruption

 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/7064183?holding=ukpmc

Effect of adrenalectomy or sympathectomy on spinal cord blood flow

After sympathectomy, RSCBF (regional spinal cord blood flow) was unchanged during hypothermia. In the cauda equina, flow fell in all hypothermic rats. The hypothermia-associated increases in RSCBF were not related to changes in mean arterial blood pressure. We conclude that adrenalectomy near-totally ablates the hypothermia-associated increase in RSCBF measured in intact rats and that abdominal sympathectomy totally ablates it. This evidence complements morphological evidence for adrenergic innervation of the spinal cord vasculature.Am J Physiol. 1991 Mar;260(3 Pt 2):H827-31. 

Ultrastructural changes in the nerves innervating the cerebral artery after sympathectomy
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/5498231?holding=ukpmc

The angina-relieving effects of sympathetic blockade

In the 1930's it was recognised by neurosurgeons performing destructive sympathectomies for angina pectoris that local anaesthetic infiltration around the stellate ganglion often resulted in pain relief outlasting the duration of action of the local anaesthetic drug^13. This observation has been more recently confirmed¹⁴, and is currently (June 1999) the subject of a large scale randomised double-blind placebo-controlled trial funded by the British Heart Foundation.

The pathogenesis of angina and myocardial infarction pain involves the activation of the afferent sympathetic pathway. A frequent and important consequence of pain (especially when severe) is the `flight or fight' response through activation of sympathetic efferents. The clinical image of the patient with an acute myocardial infarction (cold, clammy, sweaty, anxious, tachycardic) is secondary to this adrenergic activation. Therefore, angina might be regarded as the sensory component of a positive feedback loop, which cannot under these circumstances be conceived as resulting in benefit, and which may be considered to be a maladaption.

The angina-relieving effects of sympathetic blockade might be due to interference with this maladaptive feedback loop, in a similar manner to the way in which adenosine interrupts a re-entrant tachycardia. If such a loop exists, it may partly explain chronic refractory angina and the fact that temporary interruption of this pathway has a prolonged effect on pain¹⁴. Beneficial amelioration of angina can be achieved with repeated blocks¹⁴. There does not appear to be any predictability in the length of time a patient remains pain-free after successive blocks.

http://www.angina.org/source/pro/symp_block.htm

pain states associated with the loss of sympathetic fibres

Postsympathectomy limb pain, postsympathectomy parotid pain, and Raeder's paratrigeminal syndrome are pain states associated with the loss of sympathetic fibres and in particular with postganglionic sympathetic lesions. There is a characteristic interval of about 10 days between surgical sympathectomy and onset of pain. It is proposed that this pain in man is correlated with the delayed rise in sensory neuropeptides seen in rodents after sympathectomy. These chemical changes probably reflect the sprouting of sensory fibres and may result from the greater availability of nerve growth factor after sympathectomy. The balance between the sensory and sympathetic innervations of a
peripheral organ may be determined by competition for a limited supply of nerve growth factor.
Lancet. 1985 Nov 23;2(8465):1158-60. 

Behavioral changes after sympathectomy

Six experiments are reported on the effects of 2,4,5-trihydroxyphenylethyl-amine (6-hydroxydopamine) on two-way escape and avoidance learning. Rats were tested on either escape or avoidance learning at 80 days of age after chemical sympathectomy at birth or 40 or 80 days of age. Neonatal and chronic sympathectomy (at 40 days), but not acute sympathectomy (at 80 days), resulted in depressed escape learning. Avoidance learning was affected by neonatal sympathectomy and partially by acute sympathectomy. The results have implications for the role of the autonomic nervous system in escape-avoidance learning.
J Comp Physiol Psychol 1976; 90:303-16.

normal forearm vasodilator response to mental stress was absent months or years after surgical sympathectomy

Additional indirect evidence on this topic in humans comes from a study conducted in the 1950s (3). In this study, the normal forearm vasodilator response to mental stress was absent months or years after surgical sympathectomy.
J Appl PhysiolVol. 92, Issue 5, 2019-2025, May 2002

Haematological changes during stress abolished by sympathectomy

To study haematological effects of emotional stress, blood samples were obtained from 29 healthy, normotensive, non-smoking males aged 20–34 years before, during and after 10 min of mental arithmetic. There were significant increases in pheripheral blood cell count, haemoglobin concentration, and haematocrit in response to mental stress. Parallel to these changes significant increases in heart rate, and systolic and diastolic blood pressure were observed. The relative increments of leucocyte (8%) and platelet (3·5%) count were significantly higher than the increase in haemoglobin concentration (2%). There was a significant positive correlation between the blood pressure increase and the mobilization of leucocytes, whereas the increase in erythrocyte count, haemoglobin concentration, and haematocrit showed significant positive correlations with heart rate reactivity. It is concluded that mental stress causes an increase in leucocyte and platelet count that could not solely be accounted for by the concurrent haemoconcentration.

The emotional leucocytosis observed in dogs has been claimed to be neurogenic in origin, since sympathectomy abolished the rise in leucocyte count (Garrey & Bryan, 19 3 5).
http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/journal/120731423/abstract 

sympathectomy can impair the autonomic nervous system’s increase of the heart rate in response to exercise

it has been shown that thoracic sympathectomy can impair the autonomic nervous system’s increase of the heart rate in response to exercise [6]. Although absolute tachycardia is not eliminated, given the endocrine and paracrine stimuli during exercise, the maximum heart rate reached during exercise has been shown to be significantly reduced after sympathectomy. Thus for a given workload during exercise, there will be a relative bradycardia. This may possibly affect the circulatory system’s ability to convey heat from the body core to the extremities for heat loss.
http://ats.ctsnetjournals.org/cgi/content/full/84/3/1025 

thoracic sympathectomy has been demonstrated to abolish or alter sympathetic vasoconstrictive responses in the skin, and this may contribute to abnormal peripheral vascular responses to temperature [4]. Paradoxically it has been suggested that in some cases there may be abnormal vasoconstriction rather than the expected vasodilatation after sympathectomy [5]. It is not impossible that such atypical peripheral vascular responses to rising body temperature may have contributed to impaired heat loss during exercise or to an inappropriate response to shock on the development of the heat stroke.
http://ats.ctsnetjournals.org/cgi/content/full/84/3/1025 

the abolition of sweating from the upper body as well as the axillae and both upper limbs may have significantly reduced the capacity of the patient to lose heat through sweating during exercise. Anhidrosis in the head and neck after sympathectomy affects a proportion of patients, but is often neglected in most reports of post-sympathectomy complications [3]. The loss of head and neck sweating in this patient may have further impaired overall heat loss. However we would also note that the degree of heat loss impairment after sympathectomy has never been quantified, and its effect on body temperature during exercise remains to be established.
http://ats.ctsnetjournals.org/cgi/content/full/84/3/1025

"Although thoracic sympathectomy is commonly used to reduce upper limb sweating, it may also lead to facial anhidrosis and disturbed cardiovascular responses to temperature. The resultant effect on overall body heat loss has not been documented. We present a case of a young patient with previous thoracic sympathectomy who suffered severe heat stroke after heavy exercise.

An already impaired cardiovascular system is recognized to be a significant risk factor for development of heat stroke. In the post-sympathectomy patient, the abnormal sympathetic skin response may lead to peripheral vascular failure or the reduced cardiac chronotropic response may impair the body’s capacity to compensate for shock. These may have contributed to the rapid development of shock and severe multiple organ dysfunction syndrome in this patient.
He had multiple organ dysfunction syndrome develop, with severe renal and hepatic failure, grade II hepatic encephalopathy, and disseminated intravascular coagulation. He responded remarkably well to aggressive supportive measures including forced alkaline diuresis, and he was eventually discharged home after 1 month. The patient was previously a healthy, physically fit, nonsmoker. He worked as a body building trainer and led an active, sporty lifestyle. The only significant medical history was that he had received thoracic sympathectomy for axillary hyperhidrosis 4 years ago at another hospital.

http://ats.ctsnetjournals.org/cgi/content/full/84/3/1025

Glycogen accumulation in Reissner's membrane following chemical sympathectomy

Acta Otolaryngol. 1978 Nov-Dec;86(5-6):314-30.
PMID: 213930 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]

Role of the ANS in cerebral circulation

It is proposed that the autonomic innervation of brain vessels participates in the control not only of the cerebral circulation but also of associated intracranial pressure phenomena.
Blood Vessels 1974;11:2-31

Sympathectomy alters cranial nerves and cerebral blood flow

Moya-Moya Syndrome

Moya Moya syndrome is a vasculopathy of the cranial arteries, usually the carotids, leading to progressive intracranial occlusion with distal collateral vessels. This is a very frequent cause of pediatric stroke in India(10,11). Children usually present with an acute focal deficit such as hemiplegia, whereas in later years sub-arachnoid hemorrhage is a common presenta-tion. Due to bilateral carotid involvement sometimes alternating hemiplegia is seen. The outcome varies widely without treatment. Moya Moya disease is usually idiopathic, although same radiographic pattern is seen in some patients with sickle cell disease, neuro-fibromatosis, postcranial irradiation and in various other conditions(15). There is no proven treatment of Moya Moya disease. Medical management involves use of aspirin but needs further testing. Surgical treatment involves cervical sympathectomy, intracranial graft of omentum or temporalis muscle and bypass of superficial temporal artery to the middle cerebral artery(34).

http://indianpediatrics.net/feb2000/personal.htm

sympathectomy greatly reduces ventilation

In conscious animals, cervical sympathectomy greatly reduces ventilation in normoxia and slightly affects ventilatory responses to hypoxia and hypercapnia, also suggesting an important role for these nerves in the control of breathing.
Eur Respir J 1998; 12: 177–184

reduces the amount of adrenaline

Cervical sympathectomy
A form of surgery that is useful for some people with LQTS. It reduces the amount of adrenaline and its by-products produced and delivered to the heart by certain nerves (the left cervical ganglia). It involves operating on the left neck and removing or blocking these nerves

http://www.sads.org.uk/technical_terms.htm

sympathectomy totally ablates regional spinal cord blood flow

We conclude that adrenalectomy near-totally ablates the hypothermia-associated increase in RSCBF measured in intact rats and that abdominal sympathectomy totally ablates it. This evidence complements morphological evidence for adrenergic innervation of the spinal cord vasculature.

http://ajpheart.physiology.org/cgi/content/abstract/260/3/H827

Transverse myelitis

Transverse myelitis is a neurological disorder caused by an inflammatory process of the grey and white matter of the spinal cord, and can cause axonal demyelination.
In some cases, the disease is presumed to be caused by viral infections or vaccinations and has also been associated with spinal cord injuries, immune reactions, schistosomiasis and insufficient blood flow through spinal cord vessels. Acute myelitis accounts for 4 to 5 percent of all cases of neuroborreliosis.^[1] Symptoms include weakness and numbness of the limbs as well as motor, sensory, and sphincter deficits. Severe backpain may occur in some patients at the onset of the disease.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transverse_myelitis

One patient with documented transection of the cord above T5 behaved like subjects after surgical sympathectomy 

 

Increase in blood flow is generally followed by a rise in skin temperature but decrease in blood flow in response to the Gibbon-Landis procedure after sympathectomy is not necessarily accompanied by a fall in surface temperature. This poor correlation between skin temperature and blood flow confirms the previous report of Hoobler and co-workers and helps define the limits of usefulness of measurements
of skin temperature as an index of blood flow to the extremity.

The vasomotor responses to the Gibbon-Landis procedure (reflex response to warming) were studied in hemiplegic patients, subjects with "high transection" of the cord, and in sympathectomized patients.

One patient with documented transection of the cord above T5 behaved like subjects after surgical sympathectomy.
Of 11 sympathectomized limbs tested for vasodilatation in response to the Gibbon-Landis procedure, 4
showed no response, while 7 responded with decrease in blood flow (vasoconstriction).

Vasomotor Responses in the Extremities of Subjects with Various Neurologic Lesions
I. Reflex Responses to Warming
By WALTER REDISCH, M.D., FRANCISCO T. TANGCO, M.D., LOTHAR WERTHEIMER, M.D.,
ARTHUR J. LEWIS, M.D., J. MURRAY STEELE, M.D.
1957;15;518-524 Circulation

inhibition of sympathetic activity and a possible impairment of endothelial function

Alterations in skin microcirculation induced by brachial plexus block can be evaluated by wavelet transform of the laser Doppler flowmetry signal. Brachial plexus block reduces the oscillatory components within the 0.0095- to 0.021- and 0.021- to 0.052-Hz intervals of the perfusion signal. These alterations are related to inhibition of sympathetic activity and a possible impairment of endothelial function.

Anesthesiology:

September 2006 - Volume 105 - Issue 3 - pp 478-484

Clinical Investigations

Endothelial dysfunction, or the loss of proper endothelial function, is a hallmark for vascular diseases, and often leads to atherosclerosis.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Endothelium

'Emotional' sweating regulated by neocortex and limbic cortex

Careful observations showed that the forearm sweating responded diversely to various mental stimuli, unlike the palmar sweating whose response was always an increase. Mental arithmetic, mental testing and physical exercise caused an immediate increase in the palmar sweating but often elicited a transient decrease in the forearm sweating, whereas pain, noise, and emotional stimuli consistently provoked an increase of sweating on the forearm as well as on the palm. These observations suggest that the activities of higher centers, presumably involving neocortex and limbic cortex, exert various influences on the central mechanisms of palmar and generalized sweating.
Jpn J Physiol. 1975;25(4):525-36.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/1206808 

90% may experience Gustatory sweating after surgery for Hyperhidrosis

Some individuals (up to 90%) may experience another type of sweating that is increased while eating or smelling certain foods (gustatory sweating) (Hornberger).Source: Medical Disability Advisor

Publish Post

http://www.mdguidelines.com/sympathectomy

 

Receptor hypersensitivity is a common problem after significant sympathetic injury

Because of their size and location, injuries to the sympathetic ganglia or chain is rarely indicated or performed. Receptor hypersensitivity is a common problem after significant sympathetic injury, including clammy hands, erythema, and allodynia. When sympathetic nerves regenerate, they may establish aberrant connections to sensory receptors, muscles, or other sympathetics receptors; this may lead to an over-response or abnormal response.
http://wiki.cns.org/wiki/index.php/Injury,_Sympathetic_Nerve

This article has been reviewed by the NeuroWiki Editorial Board

because bilateral ETS causes the suppression of cardiovascular response to exercise, patients need to be observed during high-level exercise

HR and BP at rest and cardiovascular response to exercise were similar in patients with palmar hyperhidrosis before ETS and in the normal control population. Therefore, we consider that patients with palmar hyperhidrosis have no overactivity of the sympathetic nerve. However, because bilateral ETS causes the suppression of cardiovascular response to exercise, patients that has been treated with ETS need to be observed during high-level exercise.

http://iars.org/abstracts/browsefile/browse.asp?command=N&absnum=45&dir=S190

Informed consent - from the ETS forum

Physicians are required to gain informed consent prior to administering a treatment. Informed consent is gained by providing patients with a full accounting of the risks of the treatment as documented in peer-reviewed, published medical/scientific literature.

Your scenario of surgeons being flummoxed by unhappy patients complaining after surgery doesn't hold water. The rules of professional medical ethics require that the treating physician be well versed in the published literature on the treatments he delivers.

There is a mountain of published research (spanning nearly a century) documenting the adverse effects of sympathectomy. There are numerous studies, for example, showing very high rates of severe side effects and studies showing that satisfaction diminishes substantially over the long term.

It is a doctors job to know this stuff and it is their ethical duty to disclose that information to patients.

So, I see the blame thing as pretty cut and dry. Surgeons perfoming sympathectomies routinely withhold information vital to informed consent. Anyone who does objective comparison between what is documented in medical/scientific literature and what is typically disclosed to prospective ETS patients has no choice but reach this conclusion.

And, to make matters worse, many surgeons use testimonials from a hand-selected group of their happiest patients to advocate the surgery. That practice is considered unethical by all medical professional organizations.

http://etsandreversals.yuku.com/directory

ETS can rarely, if ever, be used effectively to treat hyperhidrosis

There are many physicians who argue that the high risk of complications after ETS surgery, and the relatively low rates of post-ETS satisfaction as a result of these problems, mean that ETS can rarely, if ever, be used effectively to treat hyperhidrosis.
International Hyperhidrosis Society

Patients with a T2 lesion were significantly more likely to have severe compensatory sweating than those with other levels

Patients with a T₂ lesion were significantly more likely to have severe compensatory sweating than those with other levels; 48.8% vs 16.1% (p <> T₂ reported high degrees of satisfaction unrelated to their postoperative compensatory symptoms. CONCLUSIONS: Patient satisfaction and perceived effectiveness with sympathectomy for palmar or axillary hyperhidrosis remain high even one year after the procedure. Inclusion of the T₂ lesion results in significantly more severe compensatory sweating and reduced satisfaction than other levels.
http://ats.ctsnetjournals.org/cgi/content/abstract/81/4/1227
Ann Thorac Surg 2006;81:1227-1233

Significant compensatory sweating in relation to the level(s) of sympathetic chain division occurred in T2 alone, 45%

Significant compensatory sweating was seen in 33% patients overall and occurred in 29% of patients with palmar symptoms, 26% of axillary patients, and 42% of facial blushers. Significant compensatory sweating in relation to the level(s) of sympathetic chain division occurred in T2 alone, 45%; T2 to T3, 30%; T3 to T4, 14%; T2 to T4, 38%; and more than three levels, 49%.

Ann Thorac Surg 2008;85:390-394. doi:10.1016/j.athoracsur.2007.08.001

Thoracoscopic Sympathectomy at the T2 or T3 Level Facilitates Bradykinin-Induced Protein Extravasation in Human Forearm Skin

The endogenous peptide bradykinin (BK) is an inflammatory mediator that induces nociceptor activation and sensitization as well as protein extravasation and vasodilation.

Conclusions. Forearm skin perfusion is increased after ETSC on the T2 or T3 level indicating decreased sympathetic activity while BK-induced protein extravasation was increased. These results show that preganglionic sympathectomy does not diminish bradykinin-induced protein extravasation as found for postganglionic sympathectomy in rats.
Stefan Leis, MD,*^† Nicola Meyer, MD, ^† Andreas Bickel, MD, ^† Christoph H. Schick, MD, ^‡§ Sophie Krüger, MD, ^§ Martin Schmelz, MD, ^¶ and Frank Birklein, MD**

Pain Medicine

Published Online: 1 Mar 2010

© 2010 American Academy of Pain Medicine

About 40% of ETS2 groups and 25% of ETS3 group patients were unsatisfied with their operation.

(Surgery 2008;143:784-9.)

Complications of sympathectomy

The excision of axillary sweat glands can cause unsightly scarring and transthoracic sympathectomy (either open or endoscopic) can be associated with complications of compensatory and gustatory hyperhidrosis, Horner syndrome and neuralgia, some of which patients may find worse than the condition itself.
American Journal of Clinical Dermatology; 2003, Vol. 4 Issue 10, p681-697, 17p

lesser imbalance of the autonomic nervous system - an oxymoron?

Ramicotomy is a surgical procedure, with less adverse effects than conventional sympathectomy, however, it was abandoned due to the high recurrence rate.

With the purpose of using a less aggressive surgical approach and lesser imbalance of the autonomic nervous system, the ramicotomy was proposed.
Ramicotomy allows complete section of all rami communicantes of the sympathetic ganglia. The histological regeneration might be greater than the recurrence rates of clinical symptoms seen in a human being due to non-functional regenerations.

Interact CardioVasc Thorac Surg 2009;9:411-415.

Referring an anxious patient with palmar hyperhidrosis to surgery may constitute malpractice

"A surgical treatment for anxiety-triggered palmar hyperhidrosis is not unlike treating tearfulness in major depression by severing the nerves to the lacrimal glands."

"Referring an anxious patient with palmar hyperhidrosis to surgery without first completing a proper trial of psychotropic medication may constitute malpractice especially if the patient experiences some of the more severe surgical complications which can occur during sympathectomy" (Bracha et al. 2006 emphasis added)

Thermoregulatory dysfunction

A published case study from the Annals of Thoracic Surgery characterizes cold sensitivity as a "new side effect" of sympathectomy. The authors describe a patient who, when "exposed to cold, the right hand and forearm become numb and the skin temperature drops to uncomfortable levels, while the left extremity remains comfortably warm." They also comment on the state of the mainstream literature, noting that sensitivity to cold was "previously unreported". Lowe et al. 2005.

Additional confirmation of thermoregulatory difficulties comes from ETS surgeon David Nielson, whose advertising website has, since 2003, listed “heat intolerance” among the “side effects” produced by the surgery. Nielson website

The empirical confirmation for the thermoregulatory problems comes from an as yet unpublished study by David Goldstein at National Institutes of Health. In addition to his published neurocardiology findings about ETS patients, Goldstein has begun thermoregulatory investigations.

The patients are fitted with what Goldstein jokingly calls a “superhero vest”. Water is pumped into the vest, and the temperature of the water can be controlled very accurately. A thermometer probe is placed in the ear to monitor how well the patient is maintaining core body temperature against both the cold and hot water in the vest.

Goldstein has written as his interpretation of one test:

"The change in core temperature of about 0.4ºC during manipulation of skin temperature would be consistent with decreased ability to maintain core temperature in response to changes in environmental temperature."

"There was evidence for a decreased ability to maintain core temperature in response to changes in environmental temperature. Taken together, there was evidence for multiple direct and indirect effects of bilateral thoracic sympathectomy that would be expected to interfere with the ability to maintain homeostasis in response to a variety of stressors."

“The efficiency of SBC (Selective Brain Cooling) is increased by evaporation of sweat on the head and by ventilation through the nose.” (Nagasaka et al. 1998)

“A necessary condition for SBC is a high heat loss capacity from the head itself, without such a heat loss SBC is not possible.” (Cabanac 1993)

“Because the human head sweats more than the rest of the body, heat loss from the head skin could amount to 125-175 Watts under conditions of moderate hyperthermia.” (Cabanac 1993)
http://editthis.info/corposcindosis/Changes_to_Systemic_Function,_part_1

ETS surgeons advertise the procedure that will disrupt 'signals to the overactive nerve'

First, it is impossible to isolate the “sweat gland nerves” because such nerves do not exist. Nerves leading to the sweat glands are all bundled together with nerves leading to many other effectors, such as the heart, the lungs, blood vessels, thyroid, bone, bone marrow, arrector pili, adipose tissue, senory nerves, etc. (the “bundling” problem).

Second, even if we wanted to stop nerve function to all sorts of effectors, it is impossible to treat “just the hands”. Each individual sympathetic ganglion serves a much larger region than that. It is generally true that ganglia higher up along the sympathetic chain innervate structures higher up in the body, but there is no possible way to isolate that portion that serves just “the hands” (the “overlap” problem).

Third, there can be significant individual differences in innervation from patient to patient, which are not discernable to the surgeon (the “individuality” problem).

Hence the results of thoracic sympathectomy remain somewhat unpredictable, and denervation is always far more extensive than desired.
http://editthis.info/corposcindosis/The_Corposcindosis_Model

empirical support for any such degree of specificity is mostly absent

Surgeons have made various claims about achieving high degrees of specificity with their own brands of ETS surgery. For example, Timo Telaranta and Chien Lin devised the Lin-Telaranta classification system:

• Sweating of the hands - T4
• Sweating and Facial Blushing - T3
• Blushing of the face alone - T2
• Social anxiety with Facial Blushing - T2
• Social anxiety without Facial Blushing - T3 and T4 on the left side only
• Heart racing and rhythm disorders - T3, T4, and T5 on the left side only (Lin et al. 2001)

Other surgeons have made different, yet no less specific, claims. Many examples have emerged of surgeon advertising websites which state or imply that ETS can target sweat glands exclusively, or can target the hands to the exclusion of other body regions.

However, empirical support for any such degree of specificity is mostly absent, and contradictory data is present. For instance, a study in France showed a lowered cardiac response to exercise after ETS, even if they only operated on one side, and it didn’t matter which side it was. The authors said this was consistent with the “random distribution” of cardiac fibers noted in anatomical studies. (See Abraham et al. 2002). Yet Goldstein and colleagues at NIH produced a graph which appears to indicate that unilateral sympathectomy does not produce the same amount of denervation as does bilateral.

An early study demonstrated a “bottleneck” effect at T2. The authors presented evidence that denervation of the top 1/3 of the body was complete, whether the surgeons took just T2, or T2-T3, or T2-T4. (see Hyndman et al. 1942)

http://editthis.info/corposcindosis/The_Corposcindosis_Model

Patients should be clearly warned that TES is not as minor a procedure as usually asserted

Although morbidity was low, significant complications of TES occurred. Patients should be clearly warned that TES is not as minor a procedure as usually asserted. Complications as well as adverse effects should be considered when discussing this surgical indication.
Ann Thorac Surg 2001;71:1116-1119
© 2001 The Society of Thoracic Surgeons

rhinitis in 9.9% and gustatory sweating in 50.4%

Dry limbs were immediately achieved in 92% (CTS) and 97% (VATS, p = 0.98). Only one patient (CTS) underwent conversion due to bleeding. In the CTS group Horner's syndrome occurred in 2.2% and rhinitis in 9.9% of procedures. No patient of the VATS group experienced Horner's syndrome (p = 0.025), 3 patients developed rhinitis (p = 0.11). At follow-up compensatory sweating was observed in 67.6% vs. 55.6% (p = 0.051) and gustatory sweating in 50.4% and 33.3% (p = 0.01). There were 5 failures or recurrences (1.9%) in the CTS group and 2 (2.8; p > 0.05) in the VATS group at reevaluation. Overall 6.5% (CTS) and 5.6% (VATS) of patients regret the operation (p = 0.7).
Ann Chir Gynaecol. 2001;90(3):195-9.

Experimental selective sympathicotomy (ramicotomy) and sympathetic regeneration

Ramicotomy is a surgical procedure, with less adverse effects than conventional sympathectomy, however, it was abandoned due to the high recurrence rate.

Ramicotomy allows complete section of all rami communicantes of the sympathetic ganglia. The histological regeneration might be greater than the recurrence rates of clinical symptoms seen in a human being due to non-functional regenerations.

Interact CardioVasc Thorac Surg 2009;9:411-415. doi:10.1510/icvts.2009.202150

36% intense 'compensatory sweating'

The results and complication rates have not necessarily been similar in reports worldwide. This can be explained in part due to the lack of clear-cut definitions for the indications, success, complications, side effects, and short- and long-term follow-up data of the procedures. It is well known that sympathectomy is often complicated by CH; the reported incidence rates vary greatly from 30% to 84% [15]. In our series it has been noted in 62.5% of the patients (26.5% moderate and 36% intense).

Although VATS sympathectomy is a simple and quick procedure, unusual complications such as chylothorax may occur [16]. However, lethal or potentially serious complications have also been reported [8, 17, 18], such as subclavian artery injury, damage to brachial plexus, large hemothorax, cerebral edema, neurologic sequelae, sinus bradycardia, and cardiac arrest.
Ann Thorac Surg 2003;76:886-891

73% of patients suffered form 'gustatory sweating' and variety of phenomena

In a series of 100 bilateral upper dorsal sympathectomies performed for palmar hyperhidrosis,
gustatory sweating and other gustatory phenomena were reported by 68 of 93 patients (73%),
followed up for an average of 11/2 years. These gustatory phenomena were quite different from
physiologic gustatory sweating: a wide range of gustatory stimuli caused a variety of phenomena in varied locations. There was a negative correlation between the incidence of these phenomena and the occurrence of Horner's syndrome after sympathectomy. Analysis of our observations, and of clinical and experimental work of others, leads to the conclusion that gustatory phenomena after upper dorsal sympathectomy are the result of preganglionic sympathetic regeneration or collateral sprouting with aberrant synapses in the superior cervical ganglion.
•
Arch Neurol. 1977;34(10):619-623.

Patients who have undergone sympathectomy are not suitable controls. Why?

Again, patients admitted with any malignancy, cholecys- tectomy, thyroidectomy, renal disease, cardiac disease, sympathectomy, or vascular graft were eliminated as controls.

This article reviews the evidence that neuroleptics may increase the risk of breast cancer via their effects on prolactin secretion.

Paul M. Schyve; Francine Smithline; Herbert Y. Meltzer
Neuroleptic-induced Prolactin Level Elevation and Breast Cancer: An Emerging Clinical Issue
Arch Gen Psychiatry, Nov 1978; 35: 1291 - 1301.

The results of endoscopic sympathectomy deteriorate progressively from the immediate outcome

This report examines the intermediate-term results of endoscopic transaxillary T2 sympathectomy for palmar hyperhidrosis.

Fifteen patients (16 per cent) developed recurrent sweating, but none required reoperation.

Twelve patients (13 per cent) were dissatisfied with the operative results, mainly owing to compensatory hyperhidrosis, which occurred in 88 patients (97 per cent) within the first year.

The results of endoscopic sympathectomy deteriorate progressively from the immediate outcome.

British Journal of Surgery

Volume 86 Issue 1, Pages 45 - 47

Published Online: 2 Jan 2003

marked dysaesthesia over the front of the chest and in the axilla

Thirty-five patients were followed up after an average of 7.8 years (range 2-17 years). In one patient unilateral reoperation was carried out four months after the first operation. Since the first operation 34 patients had suffered from neither palmar nor axillary sweating. However 20 had permanent compensatory hyperhidrosis, and 15 suffered from gustatory facial sweating, which had usually started within six months of operation. Four, in whom two spinal thoracic nerves had also been resected, reported marked dysaesthesia over the front of the chest and in the axilla, lasting for several years.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/1114879

Psychoneurological applications of endoscopic sympathetic blocks

In addition to more widely and longer known indications of ETS, various neurological disorders and psychologically stressful situations in their worst expressions might be alleviated by the reversible ESB procedure. The patients with social phobia, especially those who have also blushing and/or stage fright type of heart racing, benefit from the ESB. The disturbances of the sympathetic nervous system, e. g. in Parkinson's disease and multiple system atrophy might be alleviated with sympathetic block, especially the extrapyramidal symptoms in these diseases. In migraine, sympathetic surgery has been noted to give some help. The unilateral left-sided block has been effective in long QT-syndrome type arrhythmias. In schizophrenia, the phobic, paranoic or confusional reactions have been tentatively treated by the sympathetic block.
Clin Auton Res. 2003 Dec;13 Suppl 1:I20-1; discussion I21.

Other therapies included sympathectomy, severing the nerves to blood vessels (a surgery with a great risk of complication!)

Your money or your life: strong medicine for America's health care system

By David M. Cutler

Oxford University Press US, 2005

Extensive surgery or burning causes nerve scaring, which may behave like epilepsy of the autonomous nervous system

Extensive surgery or burning causes nerve scaring, which may behave like epilepsy of the autonomous nervous system and cause the well known devastating side effects.
http://sympathectomy.info/

Sympathectomy limits blood flow to a vital organ like the brain

However, sympathetic blockade at the level of the neck eliminated the beta-1 blockade induced attenuation in delta MCA V(mean) (10.2 2.5 cm s(-1)). These results indicate that a reduced ability to increase CO during exercise limits blood flow to a vital organ like the brain and that this flow limitation is likely to be by way of the sympathetic nervous system.

PMID: 10971220 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]
1. Acta Physiol Scand. 2000 Sep;170(1):33-8.

decrease of hyperhidrosis in the zones regulated by mental or emotional stimuli

Redistribution of perspiration as reported by the patients comprised significant reductions in palmar and axillary hyperhidrosis, and an increase in the zone of the trunk and popliteal region. The incidence of plantar anhydrosis and plantar hypohidrosis was 30.3% and 20.7%, respectively (p < 0.001). Conclusions: EBTS is followed by redistribution of body perspiration, with, and important, plantar anhydrosis and hypohidrosis. Although EBTS is the standard treatment for palmar primary hyperhidrosis, we must continue studying baseline sympathetic activity in patients affected by primary hyperhidrosis and the neuroanatomy of the sympathetic system to understand the redistribution of sweating and decrease of hyperhidrosis in the zones regulated by mental or emotional stimuli.
European Journal of Cardio-Thoracic Surgery, Volume 36, Issue 2, August 2009, Pages 360-363

Receptor hypersensitivity is a common problem after significant sympathetic injury

Because of their size and location, injuries to the sympathetic ganglia or chain is rarely indicated or performed. Receptor hypersensitivity is a common problem after significant sympathetic injury, including clammy hands, erythema, and allodynia. When sympathetic nerves regenerate, they may establish aberrant connections to sensory receptors, muscles, or other sympathetics receptors; this may lead to an over-response or abnormal response.
http://wiki.cns.org/wiki/index.php/Injury,_Sympathetic_Nerve

Perioperative risks are low, but complications can be devastating

Endoscopic thoracic sympathectomy (ETS) involves division of the thoracic sympathetic chain between T2 and T4.

The main indication for ETS is the treatment of palmar hyperhidrosis.

The most common method of anaesthesia for ETS uses intermittent positive pressure ventilation via a standard tracheal tube.

Perioperative risks are low, but complications can be devastating.

• Medicine
• BJA: CEACCP
• Volume 9, Number 2
• Pp. 52-55

symptoms subsequently deteriorated

We describe a patient who underwent upper thoracic sympathectomy for palmar hyperhidrosis, and whose symptoms subsequently deteriorated, becoming worse than those on initial presentation.

---

Recurrence of hyperhidrosis after endoscopic transthoracic sympathectomy—case report and review of the literature

C.H. ORTEU ¹ , J.M. MCGREGOR ¹ , J.R. ALMEYDA ¹ M.H.A. RUSTIN ¹

¹ Dermatology Departments, The Royal Free Hospital, Pond Street, London NW3 2QG and The North Middlesex Hospital, London N18 1QX, UK

Copyright 1995 Blackwell Science Ltd

Acquired cardiovascular disease following Sympathectomy

Effects of endoscopic thoracic sympathectomy for primary hyperhidrosis on cardiac autonomic nervous activity

We found statistically significant differences (P < .05) in both time and frequency domains. Parameters that evaluate global cardiac autonomic activity (total power, SD of normal R-R intervals, SD of average normal R-R intervals) and vagal activity (rhythm corresponding to percentage of normal R-R intervals with cycle greater than 50 ms relative to previous interval, square root of mean squared differences of successive normal R-R intervals, high-frequency power, high-frequency power in normalized units) were statistically significantly increased after sympathectomy. Low-frequency power in normalized units, reflecting sympathetic activity, was statistically significantly decreased after sympathectomy. Low-/high-frequency power ratio also showed a significant decrease, indicating relative decrease in sympathetic activity and increase in vagal activity.

The Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery
Volume 137, Issue 3, March 2009, Pages 664-669

collateral effects of thoracic sympathectomy not disclosed to patients

Several reports also demonstrate significantly lower heart rate increases during exercise in subjects who have undergone bilateral ISS [9–12] compared to pre-surgical levels. In spite of this high occurrence, recent reviews on the usual collateral effects of thoracic sympathectomy still do not include these possible cardiac consequences [6].
Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 2001;20:1095-1100

Laparoscopic surgery is associated with an increased incidence of postoperative atelectasis

Atelectasis occurs regularly after induction of general anesthesia, persists postoperatively, and may contribute to significant postoperative morbidity and additional health care costs. Laparoscopic surgery has been reported to be associated with an increased incidence of postoperative atelectasis.
Anesth Analg 2009; 109:1511-1516
© 2009 International Anesthesia Research Society

Patients should be warned about sever sweating before thoracic sympathectomy.

The operation also reduced pedal sweat production in 12 of the 29 patients who suffered concomitant pedal hyperhidrosis. Compensatory truncal sweating occurred in 36 of the 42 patients; it was severe in ten, moderate in 16 and minimal in ten.

Source: British Journal of Surgery, Volume 84, Number 12, December 1997 , pp. 1702-1704(3)

Publisher: John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Reversal surgery for reducing the side effects of ETS

Telaranta T. A case report. Ann Chir Gynaecol 2001; 90: 175 - 6.

Pain following endoscopic sympathectomy

The mean postoperative follow-up period was 11.5 months (range, 3-25 months). The hands of all patients were warm and dry after operation. No conversion to open surgery was necessary, and no operative mortality was recorded in either group. The mean inpatient pain scores were significantly higher in the biportal group (1.2 +/- 0.6) than that in the uniportal group (0.89 +/- 0.5, P=0.025). For the first three weeks after operation, four out of 20 (20%) patients in the uniportal group constantly suffered from mild or moderate residual pain while eight out of 25 (32%) cases in the biportal group (P=0.366). Among them, two cases in the uniportal group and five cases in the biportal group need to take analgesics.
Medical Devices & Surgical Technology Week. Atlanta: Sep 6, 2009. pg. 203

83% of patients reported severe 'compensatory sweating'

Fully 83% of patients who underwent T2 sympathectomy reported severe compensatory sweating one year after surgery and the majority of those reported they regretted the decision to have the surgery.
Heather Ennis. Medical Post. Toronto: Feb 15, 2005. Vol. 41, Iss. 7; pg. 17, 2 pgs

Obviously, it is not simply a compensatory hyperhidrosis transposition

Obviously, it is not simply a compensatory hyperhidrosis transposition from postoperative reduction of palmar sweating. Based on our observations, we postulated two possible
mechanisms. The first of these mechanisms is denervation hypersensitivity of the
surgically injured distal sympathetic stump. This could explain why CH may appear
soon after sympathectomy, but is not found in patients who undergo local excision of
axillary sweat glands or undergo local treatment. Another mechanism is regeneration
of preganglionic fibers or collateral sprouting of sympathetic fibers from the proximalstump of the sympathetic trunk. This could explain the long-termexistence
of PCH.
Ann Thorac Surg 2001;72:667-668

autonomic neuropathy in which the sympathetic nerve function has been divided into two distinct regions

CS or compensatory hyperhidrosis is the most common and troublesome side-effect of hyperhidrosis surgery and is the leading cause of patient regret after sympathetic surgery.
A severe form of CS is the split-body syndrome, corposcindosis, which is defined as an
autonomic neuropathy in which the sympathetic nerve function has been divided into two distinct regions, one dead and the other hyperactive. In these cases, the patient feels like he or she is living in two separate bodies.
The rates of CS in some series from the past 10 years are summarized in Table 4, with rates of mild CS varying from 14% to 90% and severe CS from 1.2% to 30.9%.
Some investigators only report on patients who have severe CS because they believe that almost all patients develop mild CS after sympathectomy.
Pascal DUMONT Thorac Surg Clin 18 (2008) 193–207

26.3% or one quarter of patients with compensatory hyperhidro- sis considered the complication major and disabling

The incidence of compensatory hyperhidrosis did not seem to be different after open or endoscopic approach.
Irrespective of approach, two or more levels of denervation and removal of the stellate ganglion produced noticeably higher incidence. Finally, the incidence of this complication seemed to be 3 times higher when the surgery was performed for primary hyperhidrosis than neuropathic pain.

The weighted mean incidence of gustatory sweating after upper extremity surgical sympathectomy was 32.3% (range 0-79) (information retrieved from 44 papers and 5,142 patients)
The phenomenon appeared on average 5 months after surgery. The weighted means appeared substantially greater when the open approach was used, two or more levels were denervated, the chain was electrocoagulated but left in situ and primary hyperhidrosis was the indication for the intervention.

The weighted mean incidence of phantom sweating was 38.6 %

The weighted mean incidence of neuropathic pain complications was 11.9% .
I S I S
SCIENTIFIC NEWSLETTER
Volume 4 Number 2
Summer Issue 2001

Botulinum toxin treatment for a compensatory hyperhidrosis subsequent to an upper thoracic sympathectomy

Compensatory hyperhidrosis is the commonest complication of sympathectomy, but there's no known effective treatment.

METHODS: Botulinum toxin type A was used successfully to treat a 68-year-old male with a 5-year history of compensatory hyperhidrosis of the anterior chest following thoracic sympathectomy for palmar hyperhidrosis.

J Dermatolog Treat. 2002 Jun;13(2):91-3.

Mia: Control of the palmar HH is considerably easier (cheaper, and smaller surface area) than the are of the chest. The so called "compensatory sweating" can also occur on the entire lower body and limbs. To use surgery as a first line treatment and then having to inject Botox to treat the side-effects od an elective procedure is close to medical negligence.

There is potentially a number of safety issues associated with this procedure

Australian Review of ETS surgery, 2009

"A lack of high quality randomised trial evidence on ETS means that it is difficult to make a judgment on the safety and effectiveness of this technique. There is potentially a number of safety issues associated with this procedure. ASERNIP-s suggests that a full systematic review including all available comparative and case series information, together with clinical inpuut, should be undertaken to provide up-to-date and comprehensive assessment of the safety and effectiveness of ETS." (ASERNIP-s Report No. 71, August 2009)

they are prone to bias and have significant methodological problems

Australian Review of ETS surgery - 2001

The four case series were not critically appraised because they are prone to bias and have significant methodological problems. These studies represent level IV evidence according to the NHMRC criteria and one should not draw firm conclusions from their findings.

To date, the benefits or side effects associated with endoscopic thoracic sympathectomy for treating facial blushing have not been properly evaluated and reported.

Further research using a well-designed controlled trial is warranted to assess the efficacy of endoscopic thoracic sympathectomy for treating facial blushing.

Centre for Clinical Effectiveness - Monash

poor* evidence is available about ETS as regards side effects, risks, and short-term effects

Swedish Review

The findings by SBU Alert show that poor* evidence is available about ETS as regards side effects, risks, and short-term effects. There is no* scientific evidence demonstrating the long-term results of the method or its cost effectiveness in relation to other methods.
(Swedish Council on Technology Assessment in Health Care (SBU), the Medical Products Agency, the National Board of Health and Welfare, and the Federation of Swedish County Councils.
Published: 1999-08-30 Revised: 2002-09-30